Tuklasin ang mga sagot sa iyong mga katanungan sa Imhr.ca, ang pinaka-mapagkakatiwalaang Q&A platform para sa lahat ng iyong pangangailangan. Maranasan ang kadalian ng paghahanap ng eksaktong sagot sa iyong mga tanong mula sa isang malawak na komunidad ng mga eksperto. Maranasan ang kadalian ng paghahanap ng eksaktong sagot sa iyong mga tanong mula sa isang malawak na komunidad ng mga eksperto.
Sagot :
G Y G E S
We can all imagine situations where a just person is unjustly killed or imprisoned. Plato would certainly have been able to think of Socrates as one such example. But as bad as Socrates’ fate was, he was an aged man, who had lived a full life. What of someone, young and innocent, falsely accused of an injustice who might spend an entire life in prison? How does his life, just though it may be, stack up against the life of someone unjust but who goes undetected?
We can all imagine situations where a just person is unjustly killed or imprisoned. Plato would certainly have been able to think of Socrates as one such example. But as bad as Socrates’ fate was, he was an aged man, who had lived a full life. What of someone, young and innocent, falsely accused of an injustice who might spend an entire life in prison? How does his life, just though it may be, stack up against the life of someone unjust but who goes undetected?The view that Glaucon puts forward is a basis for a social contract view of justice such as we will see developed later in the history of philosophy by Hobbes and others. Glaucon’s proposal implies that we are essentially self-interested and amoral. We act morally not because morality fulfills our natures but because we have no other alternative.
We can all imagine situations where a just person is unjustly killed or imprisoned. Plato would certainly have been able to think of Socrates as one such example. But as bad as Socrates’ fate was, he was an aged man, who had lived a full life. What of someone, young and innocent, falsely accused of an injustice who might spend an entire life in prison? How does his life, just though it may be, stack up against the life of someone unjust but who goes undetected?The view that Glaucon puts forward is a basis for a social contract view of justice such as we will see developed later in the history of philosophy by Hobbes and others. Glaucon’s proposal implies that we are essentially self-interested and amoral. We act morally not because morality fulfills our natures but because we have no other alternative.In responding to Glaucon’s contractarian view Plato proposes an alternative view of human nature to that of the contractarians. We are, Plato will maintain, ultimately only fulfilled as human beings by being virtuous. Justice is thus intrinsically preferable to injustice. Indeed, Plato seems in general to underline Socrates’ view that care for the soul is our fundamental good. The only real harm is harm to the soul.
Salamat sa paggamit ng aming plataporma. Layunin naming magbigay ng tumpak at napapanahong mga sagot sa lahat ng iyong mga katanungan. Bumalik kaagad. Salamat sa pagpili sa aming plataporma. Kami ay nakatuon sa pagbibigay ng pinakamahusay na mga sagot para sa lahat ng iyong mga katanungan. Bisitahin muli kami. Bisitahin ang Imhr.ca para sa mga bago at kapani-paniwalang sagot mula sa aming mga eksperto.
