Answered

Makakuha ng mabilis at tumpak na mga sagot sa lahat ng iyong mga katanungan sa Imhr.ca, ang mapagkakatiwalaang Q&A platform. Tuklasin ang aming Q&A platform upang makahanap ng malalim na sagot mula sa isang malawak na hanay ng mga eksperto sa iba't ibang larangan. Maranasan ang kadalian ng paghahanap ng eksaktong sagot sa iyong mga tanong mula sa isang malawak na komunidad ng mga eksperto.

Instruction: Read the article entitled “The Site of the First Mass” through this link.

https://upd.edu.ph/limasawa-vs-butuan-the-first-easter-mass/. After reading the article, answer the exercise below.





1. How do you understand the text? What is it all about?

2. What is your stand about the site of the First Mass?

3. How does the evidence presented in the text help you understand the controversy on the First Catholic Mass in the Philippines?

4. How this conflict affects our understanding of our own history?

5. Put yourself in the shoes of an indigenous Filipino during the time of the first mass in the Philippines. Describe your thoughts and feelings towards the arrival of Ferdinand Magellan and the holding of the first Catholic mass on Philippine soil. Reflect on the cultural, and religious implications of this historical event from the perspective of an indigenous individual during that time.

​

Sagot :

jafif67556

Answer:

The Site of the First Mass: An Analysis

The article "Limasawa vs. Butuan: the First Easter Mass" by Dr. Antonio Sanchez de Mora, published by the University of the Philippines Diliman, delves into the historical controversy surrounding the location of the first Catholic Mass in the Philippines. This article presents a compelling argument for Limasawa Island, Leyte, as the site of this significant event.

1. Understanding the Text

The text primarily focuses on the historical debate regarding the location of the first Catholic Mass in the Philippines. It presents Dr. Mora's research, which utilizes primary and secondary sources from the 16th century to pinpoint the location as Limasawa Island. The article also highlights the shift in historical consensus from Butuan to Limasawa, as well as the resistance and debates surrounding this change.

2. Stand on the Site of the First Mass

Based on the evidence presented in the article, I lean towards accepting Limasawa Island as the most likely site of the first Catholic Mass. Dr. Mora's thorough analysis of historical documents, including Magellan's expedition records, survivor testimonies, and maps, provides a strong foundation for this conclusion.

3. Evidence and the Controversy

The article clarifies the controversy by highlighting the conflicting interpretations of historical sources. The shift from Butuan to Limasawa was based on the discovery of a logbook from the ship Victoria, which indicated the presence of a cross on an island named "Mazaua" closer to Cebu. This discovery, coupled with Dr. Mora's analysis of other historical documents, strengthens the argument for Limasawa.

4. Impact on Historical Understanding

The ongoing debate surrounding the site of the first mass affects our understanding of Philippine history in several ways:

  • Historical Accuracy: It emphasizes the importance of critically examining historical sources and interpretations to ensure accuracy.

  • National Identity: The debate raises questions about national identity and the role of religion in shaping Philippine culture.

  • Cultural Heritage: It highlights the need for a deeper understanding of pre-colonial Philippine culture and its interaction with Spanish colonization.

5. Indigenous Perspective

From an indigenous Filipino's perspective during that time, the arrival of Ferdinand Magellan and the holding of the first Catholic Mass would have been a complex and unsettling experience. Here's a possible reflection:

  • Initial Encounter: The arrival of foreign ships with unfamiliar people would have been a cause for both curiosity and fear. The indigenous Filipinos would have been observing these newcomers with a mix of fascination and apprehension.

  • Cultural Clash: The imposition of a new religion and cultural practices would have been a significant challenge to their existing beliefs and traditions. The indigenous Filipinos might have felt threatened by the arrival of these outsiders and their attempts to change their way of life.

  • Religious Implications: The holding of the first Catholic Mass would have been a symbolic act of dominance and a challenge to the indigenous Filipinos' spiritual beliefs. They might have felt confused and conflicted about the new religion being introduced to them.

Umaasa kami na nakatulong ang impormasyong ito. Huwag mag-atubiling bumalik anumang oras para sa higit pang mga sagot sa iyong mga tanong at alalahanin. Salamat sa paggamit ng aming plataporma. Layunin naming magbigay ng tumpak at napapanahong mga sagot sa lahat ng iyong mga katanungan. Bumalik kaagad. Imhr.ca ay nandito upang magbigay ng tamang sagot sa iyong mga katanungan. Bumalik muli para sa higit pang impormasyon.